Our book club meeting at the library downtown turned into a debate about whether the movie was better, and nobody touched the discussion questions I printed out.

I spent like two hours on those questions too. Highlighted passages and everything. We had a solid group of 8 people who all said they finished the book. But then Sarah brought up the ending scene in the movie and suddenly it was all about casting choices and soundtracks. I get it, the visual stuff is easier to talk about. But I really wanted to dig into why the main character made that choice in chapter 12. Has anyone else had their book club just completely ignore the book part?

3 comments

3 Comments

amy_anderson1mo ago

Did anyone actually bring up the main character's choice in chapter 12 at all, or did Sarah just steamroll the whole conversation from the start? Because that moment is honestly the whole point of the book, and if nobody even mentioned it, then your group is basically just a movie club that occasionally reads a few pages. I've been there before, it's frustrating when you put real effort into prep and everyone else treats it like a casual hangout. The visual stuff is easy to talk about, sure, but it's shallow. You're trying to go deeper and they're stuck on what color the actress's dress was.

tessa_murray1mo ago

Chapter 12 is the whole reason the book exists and they just skipped over it? That's like watching a thriller and ignoring the twist because the popcorn was good. Sarah sounds exhausting honestly, always needing to be the one talking. Those groups are the worst, they turn everything into a surface level chat about movie stuff. Hope you find a better one soon.

corablack1mo ago

Isn't it the same everywhere? People just want the easy surface stuff.