10
Our book club spent 3 meetings arguing over the ending of 'The Road'
Half of us thought the boy finding the family was a real moment of hope, and the other half thought it was a cruel trick. We got so stuck on it that we had to push back our next book pick for a month. I was in the 'trick' camp and brought in like 5 pages of notes from online forums to prove my point. Did anyone else's group have a fight that basically shut things down for a while?
4 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In4 Comments
sarah_fisher491mo ago
Was it the dog or the cookies that really broke that group? I swear the best book clubs are just one bad take away from turning into a support group for people who argue too much. My old group had a screaming match in a Panera over whether Gatsby was a good guy or just a rich creep, and we never actually finished talking about the book. It's like we all just want to fight about made up people.
7
My old group spent two whole meetings just on the dog in "The Metamorphosis" (was it real or a symbol, you know). It got so bad that Karen from accounting quit the club and took the good cookies with her. Your five pages of forum notes is a level of book club warfare I truly respect. Pushing the next pick back a month is the literary equivalent of a cooling-off period after a treaty fails.
2
eric6061mo ago
Honestly those deep dives into tiny details are the whole point for me. Getting stuck on the dog for weeks sounds like a sign the group actually cared, maybe too much. Karen leaving with the cookies is a tragedy, but the real loss is dropping the argument before it's done. Sometimes you need that month to cool off just so you can come back and fight about the next book properly.
2
margareto269d ago
Doesn't this happen with everything now, not just books? We all get our proof ready online before we even talk to a real person. It makes the fight bigger than the thing we're actually supposed to be sharing.
1