26
Question about a character's lie in my last book
The main character lied to keep her friend safe, but that lie hurt a lot of other people. Our group got pretty heated arguing if the 'good' lie was worth all the bad fallout. Where do you draw the line when a character does a bad thing for a good reason?
4 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In4 Comments
the_patricia1mo ago
Forget about Jenna's guilt for a minute. Look at what the lie actually did. If it kept her safe from real, physical harm, then a little social fallout or hurt feelings is a fair trade. Protecting one person from a true threat sometimes means stepping on a few toes. The world isn't clean, and good people have to make messy choices to stop worse things from happening. The line gets drawn at the result, not the method.
7
paige5621mo ago
Look at Jenna, the friend in question. Did she ever agree to the lie that shielded her? Her potential guilt makes the 'good' reason look selfish.
4
mason_fisher1mo ago
My buddy lied to cover for his sister once, and she never forgave him for putting that guilt on her.
3